The Front Burner with Jimmy and Andrew

Episode 4 Aired: Thursday, January 28th 2016

Critical Condition

A number of long-simmering tensions between chefs and the media recently boiled over following the New York Times bombshell Per Se review. An all-star round-table representing both camps, and several generations, join Jimmy and Andrew to make sense of it all this week: Drew Nieporent, Hanna Raskin, Sam Sifton, Alex Stupak, Ryan Sutton, and David Waltuck. We discuss the complicated and evolving relationship between these two populations: Should reviews be written/consumed as entertainment? Does the star system still make sense? Why the recent critical focus on value? Is it appropriate for chefs to respond to critics and -- if so -- how? A rare opportunity to hear these two populations exchange ideas about this complex, hot-button topic.

Screen Shot 2016-01-28 at 12.13.37 PM

"A bad review is something that I don't feel a need to respond to, but I take very much to heart and I think all restauranteurs and chefs do." [16:00]

--David Waltuck on The Front Burner

"At its best, the critic can act as a translator, explainer, or reporter who is divining what is going on here culturally as opposed to what is going on here from a business perspective." [17:50]

--Sam Sifton on The Front Burner

 

Subscribe

From the Show

Tags

Sponsors

Sponsored by

Latest Episodes

All She Wrote

Episode 37, Aired: April 20, 2017

In The Front Burner's last episode (details and future plans at episode's end), we talk with Boston chef Barbara Lynch about her no-holds-barred memoir OUT OF LINE: A LIFE OF PLAYING WITH FIRE, which is about as revealing a book--by a chef or anybody--as you'll ever read. Then we welcome Chef Brock...

THE LAST MAGNIFICENT: A FRONT BURNER SPECIAL REPORT

Episode 36, Aired: April 17, 2017

Three of the biggest names in chef-land join us to discuss the new documentary JEREMIAH TOWER: THE LAST MAGNIFICENT, which opens in New York and Los Angeles this Friday, April 21. Executive producer Anthony Bourdain, director Lydia Tenaglia, and legendary chef Jeremiah Tower. Over a far-reaching...

The Human Touch

Episode 35, Aired: April 6, 2017

Front Burner regular Amanda Cohen, chef-owner of New York City's Dirt Candy, joins us to discuss a variety of subjects: the relationship between chefs and critics (from the New York Times to the civilian critics of Yelp and other open formats), the case for no-tipping, and the pleasures of her...

Peace, Love, and Understanding

Episode 34, Aired: March 30, 2017

Customers expect more from restaurants than ever before, but is what they want reasonable, or even realistic? In a business that draws people pleasers, why can't chef-owners always give the people what they want? This week Jimmy and Andrew bat around both sides of hot-button topics including...

Au Revoir, Annisa

Episode 33, Aired: March 23, 2017

After 17 years in business, Chef Anita Lo will be shuttering her beloved Greenwich Villiage, NY, restaurant this spring. Anita and her Chef de Cuisine Mary Attea join us to discuss the decision to close, the vicissitudes of the modern restaurant business, and what's next for both of them.

Paths of Glory

Episode 32, Aired: March 9, 2017

There are more ways than ever to be a chef today, something that's become a bit of a sub-theme this season on The Front Burner. This week, we talk to Brian Bistrong about the myriad opportunities available to chefs in 2017, something he knows intimately, having been chef de cuisine to David Bouley...

Related Editorial